This is an archival copy of the hunt; links and emails may not function.

Novel Ideas

ANSWER: EAST OF EDEN

Author: Andrew McManus

Questions need to be determined by trial and error. Successes will be noted but failures are not. Take the $100 question as an example:

Desired question: “What George Orwell novel talks about Big Brother?”

There are 18 possible success flags for the question:

  1. First word starts with W
  2. First word is “What”
  3. Second word starts with G
  4. Second word is “George”
  5. Third word starts with O
  6. Third word is “Orwell”
  7. Fourth word starts with N
  8. Fourth word is “novel”
  9. Fifth word starts with T
  10. Fifth word is “talks”
  11. Sixth word starts with A
  12. Sixth word is “about”
  13. Seventh word starts with B
  14. Seventh word is “Big”
  15. Eighth word starts with B
  16. Eighth word is “Brother”
  17. Word count is 8 words
  18. Overall character length (not including question mark) is 48 characters

In order, those flags (when correct) will return the words:

  1. Youth
  2. Heresy
  3. Yielding
  4. Cowardice
  5. Ennui
  6. Complaining
  7. Contrition
  8. Yawning
  9. Complications
  10. Heredity
  11. Oddity
  12. Powerlessness
  13. Entertainment
  14. Flavor
  15. Narration
  16. Ingenuity
  17. Grace
  18. Delightfulness

When the proper question is posed, an answer box will show up so that the solver can submit the title “NINETEEN EIGHTY FOUR”. Upon submitting that, the solver will be awarded a seemingly nonsensical prize of BILMSKCXWCNEP.

The remaining questions work in the same way. Questions, answers, and prizes are as follows:

DollarQuestionAnswerPrize
$100What George Orwell novel talks about Big Brother?NINETEEN EIGHTY FOURBILMSKCXWCNEP
$200What Oscar Wilde novel involves a portrait by Basil Hallward?THE PICTURE OF DORIAN GRAYPIBNQDJCCYEFE
$300What Harper Lee novel features lawyer Atticus Finch?TO KILL A MOCKINGBIRDKRCHCMEDYEBCC
$400What novel was initially titled The Innocent Voyage?A HIGH WIND IN JAMAICAEKDYIFCLEPCHC
$500What Kurt Vonnegut novel takes place in Dresden?SLAUGHTERHOUSE FIVEXYCKJLZCCIYOY

The next thing to notice is that the flag success words start with unusual letters. In fact, the initial letter for each success word maps as a cipher text to the answer itself. (In the first example, initials from the success words YHYCECCYCHOPEFNIGD maps to NINETEENEIGHTYFOUR.) This mapping is consistent through all five answers and can be used to help narrow down novel titles for questions that haven’t been answered.

Further, once the prize is translated this way, the five prizes can be read via a simple route cipher to read WHATBOOKANSWEREDFINALJEOPARDYSEPTEMBERSEVENTEENTHOFTWENTYEIGHTEEN? The answer is EAST OF EDEN.